Et tu, E-Text?
You/we/us are reading e-text in the here and now. In “normal” dialogue I/we cannot communicate except through mutual negotiation of meaning and the repair of mistaken assumptions. Or deliberate lies.
A message in any form, hieroglyph or e-reader, is not the problem. The issue is how the delivery system shapes our behavior and expectations of human-environment interaction. So what’s the beef with technology and e-books?
Per patron saint M. McLuhan (again) the medium is the massage. As applied here e-reading is delivered in sections bit by byte doled out as allowed by the screen. It is a medium that provides limited exposure to unlimited sources. It requires highly focused nanosecond attention on temporary text-as-image rather than text as extension of printed narrative. The screen is always in focus but out of context. As always, the object as thing-in-itself communicates more than the content.
Hold a book and you hold past, present and future. You hold, smell, feel, clutch and grasp a thing that contains magic words and cultural connection. Reach for the book and engage the sensorium via ink and paper. To hold a book is to hold a legacy of dead trees, a sacrificial act of martyrdom.
It is to hold a semi-conscious connection to what it means to be alive, literate and part of a culture of words, of language and ideas. In a sense, every book is a bible. To give/receive a book is to give/receive a part of someone’s mind and engage in the human act of exchange.
What goes around comes around. What we grasp also holds us by the throat, or can lead us by the hand and mind. The choice is ours only if we exercise the right to make a choice.
Technology makes choices for us by colonizing the human environment. E-books are symptoms of technological cuteness, possibly a fetish for the insecure cool and neurotic hip. The techno-portable object requires that you are also mobile and portable. Impermanent and displaceable /replaceable. You consume the object and the object consumes you as a point-of-sale marketing niche to be spit out when done.
E-readers as a technological device implement the market algorithm of consumer electronics. It’s a recipe that guarantees immediate gratification for the price of human passivity and blind faith in machines. As multiple vendors pander to each desire or impulse we then end up scattered and dispersed. The whole cannot become more than a sum of its parts if some of those parts are missing.
As a defiant act of proprioception take a pencil to paper and feel the connection between hand and imaginary ideal. So many possibilities…so many compromises and negotiated settlements! So much more than type, click and redo. Your imagination is beyond the limits of a Microsoft thesaurus.
E-books contribute to the diaspora of a cohesive human mind. It is part of a comfortable plague that demands our money, time and essence.
Literacy is a wondrous thing because it is a human invention, made by hand and at times delivered by tongue. Do not let your words arrive canned and preprocessed. Demand free-range thought and organically grown text.
No easy resolution to the contradictions that are now appearing on your screen.
Peace, at least for the time being.









